Usually, buying an old Roku player isn’t a bad idea. Roku’s software is so lightweight that performance seldom feels much different from one generation to the next. The company also takes a conservative approach to new hardware features, so you might not miss much by being a generation behind. (Last year, for instance, the 2015 Roku 3 remained a steal for HDTV owners, since Roku’s new high-end models focused on 4K video.)
This year is an exception to the rule. With the way Roku is pricing its new lineup, and some of the changes it’s introduced this year, older Roku players have become much less appealing. In most cases, you’re better off spending a little more to get a new Roku, even as prices for older ones hit all-time lows.
It’s all about the remote
The biggest change in the 2017 Roku line—with the exception of low-end Roku Express models—is a new remote with TV volume and power controls. Roku has built an infrared emitter into its remotes for the Streaming Stick, Streaming Stick+, and Ultra, and its software automatically programs the remote with just a couple clicks. (Roku’s remotes don’t include an input, but your TV can switch automatically if it supports HDMI-CEC.)
As noted in my Roku Streaming Stick and Stick+ review, the new remote feels like a revelation. TV controls were once the domain of high-end streaming boxes, like the Apple TV and Nvidia Shield TV, but now they’ve effectively been democratized. Once you’ve experienced having all the necessary controls in a single streaming remote, it’s hard to go back to juggling multiples.
Even if your TV is connected to an A/V receiver, soundbar, or other external sound system, those TV controls still have value. Roku players don’t have a sleep mode, so being able to power down the television spares you from seeing Roku’s neverending screensavers. And if your sound system supports HDMI-CEC, Roku’s volume buttons can still adjust the sound.
With that in mind, the deals we’re seeing on last-gen Roku sticks and set-top boxes don’t seem particularly appealing. You can get a 2016 Roku Streaming Stick for $40, for instance, or a refurbished model for $32, but the new Streaming Stick’s remote is such a significant improvement that it’s worth the full $50. (The new stick also adds voice commands via its remote, and it uses the latest 802.11ac Wi-Fi standard to boot.)
Last year’s Roku Ultra ($65 in some Walmart stores, $80 refurbished on Amazon) is also worth passing over in favor of the new $70 Streaming Stick+, which feels just as fast, has the same voice controls, and adds TV volume and power buttons.
Exceptions to the exception
Now, let’s backpedal a bit: There are still some scenarios where you might want to buy an older Roku.
Most notably, the new models’ TV controls won’t help much if you plan to use a universal remote. In that case, you might want to seek out last year’s Roku Premiere (reportedly $19 at some Walmart stores; not to be confused with the Premiere+), which will work with cheap infrared remotes like the Logitech Harmony. And if you have a Logitech Harmony Hub, you can use it with any recent Roku model, including last year’s Premiere+ and Streaming Stick. You won’t get Roku’s voice controls with these models, but you’re giving them up by using a universal remote anyway.
The Roku Premiere+ might also be worthwhile if your home internet setup demands wired ethernet connectivity. The Roku Ultra is now the only model that offers an ethernet jack, so the Premiere+ is a significant savings at $40 to $50 less.
And while I still strongly recommend the new Roku Streaming Stick over the cheaper Roku Express, the 2016 Streaming Stick is a better value than any Express model—new or old—if you want to save a little money and don’t care about TV controls. It supports dual-band Wi-Fi, and has an RF remote that doesn’t require line-of-sight to the box. At $32 refurbished, it’s only a couple bucks more than a brand-new Express.
Outside of these edge cases, however, most people should pass over the older Roku models and opt for the $50 Roku Streaming Stick (for 1080p televisions) and $70 Streaming Stick+ (for 4K and 4K HDR sets). You might have to pay a little more, but it’ll be worth the convenience you get in return.
Jared Newman has been helping folks make sense of technology for over a decade, writing for PCWorld, TechHive, and elsewhere. He also publishes two newsletters, Advisorator for straightforward tech advice and Cord Cutter Weekly for saving money on TV service.