Where’s the antenna support on streaming-TV boxes?
As Roku and Amazon add cool new antenna integration to their smart TVs, streaming players get left out.
By Jared Newman
TechHiveOct 5, 2017 4:00 am PDT
Image: Jared Newman / TechHive
Roku has been giving lots of love to over-the-air antennas lately, but only on its smart TVs.
Roku TVs from TCL, Hisense, and others have supported pausing over-the-air channels since last fall, and now the company is building on those features with Roku OS 8. When the update lands on Roku TVs in November, cord-cutters will get a 14-day channel guide, which also lists whether each program is available from streaming sources. Local TV listings will appear in Roku Search as well, and live broadcasts will support private listening, either through Roku’s mobile app or any Roku remote that has a headphone jack.
Unfortunately, none of this over-the-air innovation is available on Roku’s streaming players, including the slew of new Roku boxes and sticks announced this week. That’s because Roku offers no way to connect an antenna directly to its players. You can still connect an antenna directly to your TV, of course, but then you get none of the rich guide data, search integration, and time-shifting that Roku TVs offer.
Roku isn’t alone in this regard. Amazon also offers some slick antenna integration on its Fire TV Edition televisions, including time-shifting, a grid-based channel guide, home-screen integration for live channels, and the ability to tune into channels by voice. None of those features are available on Amazon’s Fire TV box or Fire TV Stick, which lack the requisite input for an antenna. (Amazon’s product page for the new Fire TV says you can “Use an HD antenna to get free broadcast networks like NBC and PBS,” but this has nothing to do with the Fire TV itself. It’s just a reference to the coaxial input on almost every television.)
There are a few legitimate challenges that Roku and Amazon face in bringing antenna support to their streaming players. But as antenna use grows in tandem with the streaming-player business, those challenges seem worth solving for the sake of a simpler cord-cutting experience.
The input problem
The biggest issue has to do with inputs. If Roku or Amazon wanted to include over-the-air integration on their streaming boxes, they’d either need a coaxial input and TV tuner inside the box itself, or on a separate USB tuner. Both approaches bring trade-offs.
Mentioned in this article
Amazon Fire TV Stick with Alexa Voice Remote (2016)
Direct coaxial input would increase the size and cost of the streaming device. That’s probably something Roku and Amazon want to avoid, given that antenna users are just a subset of the overall streaming-player market.
An optional USB tuner might make more sense, but devices like the Roku Ultra and Fire TV box only have one USB port. To pause or rewind live TV, the device would either need a second USB port for external storage, or ample built-in storage for temporarily saving the video. Either way, you’re back to the problem of added device costs for a feature that only some people might use. This could be solved with a USB hub device, through which users could connect both a tuner and a storage drive, but it’s hard to imagine Roku or Amazon backing such an unwieldy solution.
Besides, neither company supports full-blown DVR features, even on their smart TVs. You can pause live TV, but you can’t schedule recordings, set up series passes, or record more than one channel at a time. Without those features, an investment in extra antenna hardware might be tougher to justify.
In lieu of antenna integration from Roku and Amazon, other companies have come up with their own alternatives.
One option is a networked DVR or tuner, such as Nuvyyo’s Tablo and SiliconDust’s HDHomeRun. These devices connect to your router—the former via Wi-Fi or ethernet, and the latter via ethernet only—and stream live TV to apps on various devices. Tablo is also a full-blown DVR, as is HDHomeRun if you have the necessary hardware. Both offer apps for Roku and Fire TV, but unfortunately, neither option integrates with search on these devices.
If you’re not married to Roku or Fire TV, Google’s Android TV platform allows for the kind of tuner integration that those devices lack. With Nvidia’s Shield TV, for instance, you can connect a supported USB tuner and watch broadcast channels through Android TV’s Live Channels app. You can also add DVR service with Tablo Engine or Plex DVR.
Sling TV subscribers should also consider the AirTV Player, another Android TV box that has its own USB tuner. With this device, over-the-air and streaming cable channels appear together in Sling’s programming guide. While AirTV didn’t fare well in our review earlier this year, the device has steadily improved in recent months with a better guide and DVR for cable channels. AirTV was also prescient enough to include two USB slots, in case the company gets around to adding over-the-air DVR support.
My wildly speculative guess is that Roku and Amazon are watching these trends, and slowly working up to something they can offer to antenna users through their streaming boxes. By starting with smart TVs, they can put the pieces together on the software side without driving up costs or requiring any additional hardware. Hopefully it won’t be long before they make leap to streaming boxes as well.