Ecobee remains our favorite thermostat, but adding Alexa functionality seems rather extraneous.
The Ecobee3 was already our favorite smart thermostat, edging out the Nest Learning Thermostat thanks to its remote sensors and overall functionality, but we weren’t sure what to expect from the follow-up. Apparently, the answer is Alexa. The Ecobee4 plays it safe when it comes to evolving the winning thermostat line. So safe, in fact, that there’s only one major difference between the 3 and 4: the integration of Amazon’s Alexa smart assistant.
If you were thinking of upgrading your home to an Ecobee, but waiting on the latest, that purchase decision relies entirely on your interest in being able to talk directly to your thermostat. While the 4 looks almost identical to the 3, if slightly larger, it’s now packed with a speaker and microphone to accommodate its new role as a smart hub that can tell you jokes and the weather, change the temperature in the house, and, if you really want, play music from Amazon’s music service (among many other tasks).
I’m honestly not sure I see the point, but there might be some who consider this pairing one of logical convenience. If your thermostat is in a central place in the house (say a kitchen or living room) and you don’t already own any sort of Amazon Alexa hub, the Ecobee4’s ability to be a smart hub could make sense. If it doesn’t make sense, the Alexa service (which defaults as active) can be turned off at any time by tapping on the microphone icon on the unit’s main screen.
I did, however, find it a little annoying that when the function is off, the Ecobee lets you know via a bright red light band at the top of the unit that stays on until you turn the mic back on. Admittedly, the actual Amazon Echo does the same thing. I also wouldn’t recommend using the Ecobee4 for playing music unless you’re really desperate for background noise. While it’s not the worst speaker I’ve ever heard, the actual Amazon Echo’s speaker is at least a little better.
Now: Google Assistant support, too
Ecobee has finally added Google Assistant to its list of compatible smart devices, enabling users of Google Home devices—and the myriad of devices that utilize Google Assistant—a whole new way to interact with their thermostat. A unique and especially nice feature is the ability easily monitor both the main Ecobee unit and remote sensors. This means you can ask it what the specific temperature in a room with a sensor is and increase or decrease the overall temperature without ever having to get up.
All about the sensors
Aside from Alexa, the Ecobee4 is basically identical to the Ecobee3. It comes with one remote sensor just as before, uses the same app, functions identically, and uses basically the same touchscreen interface. It’s sharp, easy to use, and has excellent weather reporting.
The Ecobee is all about its remote sensor, which is the main reason why we like it so much. Far more complex than a mere remote thermometer, you can configure how you interact with your HVAC system with these sensors. For many, the actual thermostat is tucked away from the main parts of the house, so being able to put these tiny sensors in the rooms that really matter for comfort is a big deal.
Ecobee allows you to dictate things like if you just want the unit to average the temperature readings of the main unit and the sensors together or actually focus on the remote sensor(s). So, if you work from home and have the sensor in your home office, the Ecobee can adjust the temperature based purely on the readings in your office. It’s a terrific, completely logical feature we’re still shocked other manufacturers haven’t blatantly stolen.
Beyond that, the Ecobee offers home/away settings that use the motion sensors in both the main unit and remote sensors to know when someone is in a room and adjust accordingly. Setting up the Ecobee is a simple affair, as well. It asks you a few questions about your ideal temperatures and that’s basically it.
For those who like heavy-duty, down-in-the-weeds scheduling, however, Ecobee makes you work a little too hard for it. By default, the Ecobee scheduling is really only interested in three time zones: sleep, home, and away. Creating a more complicated schedule of adjustments throughout the day (like many admittedly less-smart thermostats allow) is a more complicated task. As it turns out, you can create new activities (how you organize your day) and comfort settings (the temperature you want the house during said activity), but they don’t exactly make it convenient.
You can only currently create new custom scheduling settings through the web portal and not the mobile app. Once a new setting is created through your web browser, it will appear in the scheduling options within the mobile application. Admittedly, since the Ecobee just naturally adjusts based on the motion sensors and set temperature preferences, most users probably won’t ever need to create a complex schedule.
Another concern is that while you don’t absolutely need a C wire to install it, the Ecobee comes with a wiring adapter (they call it a “power extender kit”) to get power to the unit, which can add some complication to the overall installation. Thankfully, the app and site provide excellent directions. Being a high-end thermostat, the Ecobee4 supports a wide range of systems and devices, including humidifiers, dehumidifiers, or ventilators.
The Ecobee4 is just as recommendable as the 3, but there’s little reason for current Ecobee owners to upgrade to this new iteration. Adding Alexa functionality is a neat trick, but hardly a major selling point. In fact, given that the Ecobee3’s price has dropped significantly (now $225 on Amazon) since the 4 came out, it’s probably a great time to buy the older unit if you’ve been holding off.
Editor’s note:We’ve updated the discussion of the Ecobee4’s scheduling features on September 28. The review originally reported that it wasn’t possible to create complex schedules. You can, it’s just not very easy. On November 17, we added information about the Ecobee4’s new support for Google Assistant.