While it’s great to see so much antenna innovation, there are other ways to watch broadcast TV on your own schedule, ones that don’t demand making an up-front investment in new hardware. Before you dive in with a product like Tablo, Plex DVR, or TiVo Roamio OTA, consider the alternatives.
Hulu + CBS + PBS: Doing the math
The most obvious alternative to an over-the-air DVR box is a subscription to Hulu, which offers new episodes from ABC, Fox, and NBC the day after they air. Hulu’s on-demand service costs $8 per month with ads, or $12 for a mostly commercial-free experience, and is available on pretty much every streaming device.
This still leaves you without current CBS programming, but you can add many of those shows with a CBS All Access subscription, which includes both a live network feed and on-demand episodes the day after they air. CBS All Access costs $6 per month with ads, or $10 per month for a plan that mostly excludes them. Like Hulu, CBS has apps on all the major streaming TV devices.
As for PBS, many new episodes are available for free through the PBS and PBS Kids apps on streaming devices. Some local stations also offer an expanded catalog through a service called PBS Passport, which requires a minimum $5-per-month donation.
These services do have a few catches, though: For the ad-free plans, some shows still have commercials due to contractual obligations. And with CBS All Access, several shows—including Big Bang Theory—only offer a random selection of episodes, rather than all the most recent ones. You also won’t be able to watch sports or any other live programming on ABC, NBC, and Fox through Hulu’s on-demand service.
If you can deal with those restrictions, you’ll pay between $14 and $27 per month—or $168 to $324 per year—for shows from all four networks and PBS.
How does that compare to an over-the-air DVR? Tablo’s two-tuner model, which is the cheapest whole-home DVR solution available today, costs $190 as of this writing, plus about $20 for a decent flat antenna, plus about $55 for a 1TB hard drive, plus $150 for lifetime DVR service. (Tablo service isn’t mandatory, but without it, you must schedule recordings manually, and you only get a day’s worth of guide data.) That brings you to $415 up front. After two or three years, the streaming route becomes more expensive.
The sunk cost of streaming bundles
You might not need those subscriptions, however, if you’re already paying for a streaming TV bundle with cable channels. Here are what those packages get you in terms of broadcast programming:
PlayStation Vue offers on-demand video from ABC, CBS, Fox, and NBC in its basic $30-per-month bundle, which also includes more than 40 cable channels. In some markets, Vue also includes live local broadcasts, which raises the base price to $40 per month. DVR is available for live TV, but recordings expire after 28 days. (You can check local broadcast availability here.)
Hulu’s $40-per-month, 60-channel bundle includes on-demand video from the four major broadcast networks. Live broadcasts are also available in some markets, but the base package prevents DVR ad-skipping and puts a 50-hour cap on DVR storage. Hulu charges $15 per month extra for a 200-hour DVR plan with ad-skipping allowed. (You can check local broadcast availability here.)
DirecTV Now offers on-demand video from ABC, Fox, and NBC—but not CBS—in its $35-per-month plan, with live feeds in some markets. (You can check local broadcast availability here.)
YouTube TV offers live feeds of all four broadcast networks in its $35-per-month bundle, which also includes more than 40 cable channels. YouTube’s service, however, is only available in a handful of markets. YouTube also prevents DVR ad-skipping for some channels, and recordings expire after nine months. (You can check local broadcast availability here.)
Sling TV offers on-demand video from Fox and NBC in its $25-per-month Blue package, with live feeds in some markets. Cloud DVR service costs an extra $5 per month for 50 hours of storage. (You can check local broadcast availability here.)
Obviously, a $35- or $40-per-month streaming bundle will quickly become more expensive than an over-the-air DVR. But that’s a sunk cost if you’re already planning to get one of these bundles for cable channels such as ESPN. For live broadcasts, you can always just plug an antenna directly into your TV (provided you’re within range of broadcast towers).
Filling the gaps
Beyond just subscribing to more streaming services, there might be other ways to get the programming you want.
NBC, Fox, and ABC all offer apps for streaming devices such as Roku, Amazon Fire TV, and Apple TV, and they sometimes offer free episodes shortly after they air on TV. (These networks also offer expanded access with a cable TV login, if you can mooch one.) CBS, meanwhile, streams free episodes of some recent shows via Chromecast. This isn’t the most reliable way to watch network shows, since availability can vary by channel and by program, but it does provide you with a source of free content..
You might also be able to buy individual episodes or seasons of your favorite shows through a la carte stores such as iTunes, Amazon Video, and Google Play Movies. Shows in HD typically cost $3 per episode, and around $30 per season, so this is a fine option if you only care about one or two shows from a particular channel.
Bottom line: Where OTA DVR makes sense
Ultimately, over-the-air DVR is all about control. You don’t have to worry about restrictions on ad-skipping and time-shifting, and you can keep hundreds of hours of recordings with no expiration dates. You can also record record programming from digital multicast networks such as MeTV, Buzzr, and Cozi TV, which generally aren’t available for streaming.
This does require laying out more money up front and setting up more hardware, but the payoff is fewer headaches and potentially a lot more savings down the road.
Jared Newman has been helping folks make sense of technology for over a decade, writing for PCWorld, TechHive, and elsewhere. He also publishes two newsletters, Advisorator for straightforward tech advice and Cord Cutter Weekly for saving money on TV service.