5 reasons to switch from Spotify Premium to its new free tier (and 5 reasons not to)

Freemium or Premium? The choice isn't so easy.

Michael Simon/IDG

Spotify announced a major upgrade to its mobile app at an event at the Gramercy Theater in New York City today. The service will no longer treat its free users as second-class citizens. Now, whether you're one of Spotify's 90 million free users or opt to pay $10 a month to unlock the full experience, your music will take center stage, with curated playlists, on-demand listening, and smarter playlist creation. It's so good, in fact, some users might want to consider downgrading to the free tier from the premium one. Here are five reasons why you might want to switch (and five reasons why you shouldn't):

5 reasons to go free

It's way more personal

When you sign up for the free plan inside the new Spotify app, you'll be greeted with a redesigned on-boarding screen that asks you to select your favorite artists. That sets the machine learning algorithm in motion, and you'll instantly be greeted with a playlist of songs you might enjoy. Then, as you listen, like, and hide songs, your invisible curator will become smarter and deliver more personal recommendations every day.

Spotify

Spotify's free tier is way more personal than it was before.

You can play songs on demand

This is the big one. Where Spotify's free users previously had access to all the service's playlists, they could only listen to them in shuffle mode. That's changing with the new app. Spotify will now offer 15 playlists a day to its free users—including popular ones like the awesome Rap Caviar mix—with unrestricted listening, meaning you can play the same song 100 times in a row if you'd like. Some of these playlists will be updated daily, others weekly, but Spotify promises more than 750 personalized tracks will be available for on-demand streaming every day.

It'll keep your playlists fresh

One of the Spotify app's greatest strengths over its competitors has been easy playlist creation on its mobile app. That's not changing with the new version—nor is the shuffle-only restrictions on the free tier—but there is one feature Spotify is bringing over from Premium that might help you make better mixes. As you curate your playlists, Spotify will continually suggest songs based on your musical tastes, the artists and genres you've picked, and even the name of the playlist itself. And what's more, it'll keep recommending new songs as you listen to it, so your favorite playlists won't get stale.

Spotify

You don't have to be a Premium user to get playlist assistance anymore.

It'll save your data

With the new app update, Spotify is removing one of the major pain points for its free users, mobile data usage. While free users still won't be able to download songs for offline listening, Spotify is introducing a new Data Saver toggle in Settings that will enable automatic caching of your favorite songs and playlists so you won't have to burn through you monthly data allotment while working out at the gym. With prompts based on mobile data usage, Spotify estimates this will decrease data usage by as much as 75 percent.

Radio is everywhere

One of the first things people will notice when launching the new Spotify app is that the Radio tab is gone. That means you won't be able to quickly jump into a station and start rocking out to J. Cole or Drake, but that doesn't mean you won't get a radio-style listening experience with the free tier. In fact, it's just the opposite. When you hit the Search tab now, you'll be presented with a list of genres to help the service focus on your mood. Then you'll get recommendations of artists, songs, and playlists tailored specifically for your tastes rather than generic radio stations that may or may not fit the bill.

Spotify

From search to playlists, Spotify's radio stations are everywhere now.

5 reasons to stay Premium

There aren't any ads

Obviously, ads are the main reason why people opt to pay Spotify $10 a month, and after today's update, that hasn't changed. If you don't want to hear 15-second ads between songs, stay on the Premium tier.

You have full access to Spotify's library

While Spotify is giving its free users on-demand access to hundreds of songs every day, it pales in comparison to the 35-million-song library that Premium users get. Sure, free users can search the entire catalogue, select songs for playlists, and add anything to their library, but only paid subscribers have the ability to play them whenever they like. So if you want to hear J. Cole's "Friends" without waiting for it to appear on one of the free tier's unrestricted playlists, Premium is the only way to go.

Michael Simon/IDG

You can pick and play some songs on the free tier, but only Premium gives you access to all of them.

You can listen offline

Spotify's new app might have a data-saver mode for on-the-go listening, but nothing beats the ability to download songs right to your device. If they have a spotty connection or a dwindling data pool, Spotify's free users may be out of luck, while Premium subscribers can listen for hours and hours without using a single megabyte of LTE data.

You can listen through a smart speaker

Spotify didn't announce a speaker or any other hardware at its event, so you'll still need to use a Google Home, Amazon Echo, or Sonos One (sorry HomePod fans), if you want a voice-controlled listening experience at home. But to do that you'll need a Premium subscription.

You can get Hulu for super cheap

A few weeks ago, Spotify and Hulu announced they were teaming up to offer a one-of-a-kind digital bundle. For $13 a month, you'll get a subscription to Spotify Premium (normally $10 a month) and Hulu's Limited Commercial plan (normally $8 a month). That's a savings of $5 a month or $70 a year, and it lets you choose between streaming Taylor Swift's Reputation or Margaret Atwood's The Handmaid's Tale. If that's not a double-threat, I don't know what is.