Update

TCL P-series Roku smart TV review: Dolby Vision hits the mainstream

Dolby Vision and a great user interface highlight the nicely affordable 55-inch TCL 55P607.

p1 front
Credit: TCL
At a Glance
  • TCL 55P607 55-inch class 4K UHD TV

    TechHive Rating
    $649.99 MSRP $649.99
    View
    on Amazon

Updated on July 12 to add some fresh insights on picture quality after watching new HD Blu-ray HDR content on the TCL 55P607. No entertainer likes to hit the stage on the heels of an act that killed, but such was the fate of TCL’s 55-inch 55P607 Roku-powered smart TV. It arrived at our lab on the heels of our hands-on time with the extraordinary Sony A1E OLED and Samsung Q9F QLED. That’s life.

But those are $6,000 TVs that not a lot of people can afford. The 55P607 is a mere $650 and gives you at least a percentage of the high dynamic range (HDR) experience those TVs offer—including Dolby Vision, something Samsung’s Q9F lacks. And HDR is an experience you’re going to want. That said, the P-Series HDR rendering tended to darken the picture substantially in a way that TVs capable of producing more NITs don't. If not for that, and the TCL 55P607's somewhat noticeable motion artifacts, it would've scored higher.

Design

The 33-pound, 54.6-inch, 4K UHD (3840 x 2160 resolution) TCL 55P607 utilizes a straightforward, thin-bezel design: Thin at the top and thicker below, where the electronics reside. The ports are in a recessed alcove on the right side (looking at the TV) and include one USB, one coax, one ethernet,  and three HDMI 2.0a with HDCP 2.2 (as required for protected Ultra Blu-ray movies). The only connector on the left side of the equipment bay is for the AC cord. There’s also an 802.11ac adapter onboard if you’d rather connect to the internet (and you must for setup) wirelessly.

p607 iso right TCL

The P-Series are a standard design, but also 10-bit panels that support Dolby Vision.

The feet for stabilizing the TV on flat surfaces are easy to attach, and wide enough to ward off most mishaps, though we prefer Samsung’s new better-safe-than-sorry super-wide feet. The whole deal is light enough that one reasonably fit person can un-box and set up the unit.

Remote control and user interface

While nothing fancy, and not universal (it controls only the TV), the 55P607’s remote is efficient. There are volume and mute buttons are on the right side of the remote, and a jack for the included earbuds on the left side. The whole deal is super easy once you’re used to it, though we would’ve liked the back button better if it had been located below the four-way cursor button.

On-screen user interface is an area where TCL plays backseat to no one, thanks largely to Roku, though TCL’s own pop-up settings interface is also well done. We loved the fact that nearly all the settings are on the first level. Scroll up or down to the setting you want and adjust with the right or left buttons. Most interfaces require continually drilling down into sub-menus.

On the other hand, we’re not big fans of having to log on to a website from another device to enter codes and set up a Roku account. At least you can skip the credit card info if you don’t intend to view pay content. Beyond that, setup is relatively painless.

While the TCL doesn’t automatically recognize attached devices, it does preview what the device attached to the currently selected HDMI input is playing. Choose from a list of popular device types (DVD player, Xbox, etc.) and voila! Input named.

Once you’re done with the configuring the 55P607, browsing the Roku interface is simple and of course, it being Roku, there’s tons of streaming content available. Quite a bit of which must be paid for, hence the credit card routine.

What some might not like is that the advanced settings are all on the Roku app you install on your phone. There you can change the color temperature, gamma, and there’s an 11-point white balance grid. That could keep you tweaking for a while. But really, not everyone is cell-phone centric—put the settings on the TV TCL, please.

Picture quality

p1 front TCL

The 55P607 is an average TV until you play HDR content. That’s when you can see why it costs a couple hundred dollars more than entry-level sets.

Until we got to the HDR content, the picture of our 55P607 was strictly that which we expect from a mid-range LED-backlit LCD: Decent, if not overly rich color; greens skewed slightly to the lime; reds ever so slightly to the pink; an overall bluish/cool tint compared to quantum dot and OLED models. But most people don’t notice the color palette once the movie is on. They might, however, notice the 55P607’s slight jumpiness displaying large, highly detailed pan shots and action sequences.

It’s not worse than what you’ll see on most TVs in its price range, but the defects were noticeable, and they were significantly worse with 24 frames-per-second content played from a USB stick. Via HDMI, the motion artifacts were livable, and shouldn’t bother most users.

Details were a tad fuzzier on the P-Series than with the $6,000 Samsung Q9F it was sitting beside. But again, the price difference makes that a rather unfair comparison. It was noticeable when different elements of the 72-zone LED backlight array turned on and off during our stress tests. Moire was also an occasional issue as well. But again, this is a $650 TV and the backlight issue will rarely be observed with normal content. Note that this all improved over our time with the TV via updates, so some of this is fixable. TCL seems hard at work in that regard.

TCL 55P607 Roku TV ports TCL

The TCL's 2017 P-series TVs are outfitted with one USB, one coax, one ethernet,  and three HDMI 2.0a with HDCP 2.2.

Where the P-Series separated from the like-priced competition is in brightness and support for both HDR-10 and Dolby Vision. We measured 430 nits of luminance with SDR (standard dynamic range) content and 600 nits with HDR-10 material. 600 nits isn’t amazing—it’s about 100 nits less than Sony’s E-series—but it’s enough to emphasize the bright areas in HDR material. Barely. With one or two files provided by Dolby, we like the effect. But four out of four viewers preferred the lighter color palette of the 1080p Blu-ray version of Power Rangers over the 4K Ultra HD with Dolby Vision version.The P-Series are 10-bit panels, meaning they’re capable of rendering just over a billion colors.

To encapsulate all that: we were satisfied with the P-Series picture with SDR content given the price, though we feel TCL could to a better job with motion compensation. And we were happy with some of the HDR content we played. HDR doesn’t pop to the extent it does with higher-end TVs, and we didn't like the way some of the content we played became overly dark. But with the right content, it is a step up in the viewing experience you normally get from a $650 TV. Keep in mind that HDR involves the TV deciding what to do with the content, so the 55P607's performance might improve with firmware updates.

Audio performance and apps

The sound emanating from the 55P607 is decent and loud enough for most environments; but as with many thin TVs, there’s almost no bass. You’ll most likely want to augment it with some sort of auxiliary system (sound bar, A/V receiver, etc.)

The media playback apps were quite capable, if not the best we’ve seen. The video app will play back the new Dolby files and most AVC and HEVC files, and the audio app handles FLAC, OGG, and Apple lossless in addition to MP3, WMA, and M4A.

Our only caveat is that the TV wouldn't recognize our 512GB USB drives, which left us copying stuff to smaller USB sticks. On the other hand, any USB stick greater than 16GB can be used as storage for the TV’s OTA (over the air) pause function. That’s a very nice perquisite.

Is it worthy?

TCL’s P-Series has a great interface and enough picture chops to actually do HDR at least some justice, depending on the material. It’s by far the cheapest way into Dolby Vision and HDR-10 that we’re aware of. For $650? Pretty sweet.

To comment on this article and other TechHive content, visit our Facebook page or our Twitter feed.
At a Glance
  • TechHive Rating
    $649.99 MSRP $649.99
    View
    on Amazon

    We love that you can get Dolby Vision, which demonstrably improves contrast and color in a 55-inch TV, for only $650. We don't love the motion artifacts which are very noticeable in scrolling and panning shots.

    Pros

    • Affordable Dolby Vision
    • Excellent Roku interface
    • Pause function for live TV, using USB storage

    Cons

    • Fine adjustments require a phone or tablet app
    • Noticeable judder in scrolling, panning, and action sequences
    • HDR content is rendered darker than optimal
Shop Tech Products at Amazon