Is It Time to Dump Cable TV?

A year ago, I toyed with the idea of getting rid of cable and doing all my TV watching online. In the end, I kept Comcast -- partially out of lethargy, but mostly because (A) cable is still a much better source of news-related programming than the Web, and (B) I'm very comfortable with my TiVo.

Reason (A) still strikes me as a significant argument in favor of keeping cable. With reason (B), however, I may be at a crossroads. My TiVo HD, which never worked very well, now isn't working at all -- it crashes every few minutes. I'm still trying to troubleshoot it, but I suspect that the drive is bad and will need to be replaced. That'll require an investment of money and time, and while I may go through with it, I'm also flirting with the notion of retiring the TiVo and giving up cable.

News remains the biggest argument against doing so: I still like the idea of having CNN, CSPAN, Fox News, MSNBC, and other newsy outlets readily available. On the other hand, some of this stuff is available in podcast form -- albeit after a delay -- and it's not like I'm glued to TV news every night. (I do, however, like to gorge on it when breaking events warrant, whether they involve election night or a celebrity death or the moving tale of a small boy swept away in his father's experimental balloon.)

If I cut the cable and give up TiVo, what should I replace them with? I'm still not sure. I like Roku. I own an Apple TV that I don't use much but would probably enjoy if I made an effort to rediscover it. The Boxee Box looks promising.

But the one box that offers access to the widest variety of stuff -- including an endless supply of free material -- is a PC. So I'm also toying with the notion of connecting a Windows box or Mac Mini to my Vizio and using it for Netflix, Boxee, YouTube, video podcasts, and a whole lot more. The major downside: Even a cheap PC costs a lot more than a Roku or a Boxee Box. But hey, if I'm no longer tithing to Comcast I'll have some newfound cash to spend.

I don't need to give up cable. I can afford it, and there are times that I'm very glad I have it. But more and more, I feel guilty about spending as much I do each month given how little of it I end up watching. It feels wasteful, like filling up your plate at an all-you-can-eat buffet when you know you're only going to take a bite or two.

Here's the part where I ask for your advice. What would you do? What are you doing?

Subscribe to the Now Playing Newsletter

Comments